By Arno Lampmann · Published
MagazinneuA number of critical reviews under a product. Most of them read like personal experience, but they contained claims that were simply not true.
In brief
- Outcome
- Shortly after the notice, Amazon announced the removal of all reviews that LHR Rechtsanwälte had reported for a manufacturer. No court was involved.
- Reason
- According to our report, the reviews contained verifiable, untrue statements of fact about the product or did not concern the product at all. Each notice set the actual facts against the sentences complained of.
- Consequence
- In this case we were able to successfully challenge false facts in Amazon reviews. Pure opinions stay online, and the manufacturer’s own account must be accurate.
Shortly after we reported them, Amazon confirmed that all of them would be removed. Why that worked, and why it is still no licence to silence criticism.
Removing Amazon reviews: what happened in this case
Shortly after our notice, Amazon informed us that it had initiated the removal of all reviews we had reported on behalf of our client, the manufacturer of a technical product. No court was involved. Each review was reported with a separate lawyer’s letter that identified the statements complained of, set out the actual facts next to them and explained the legal position, including Amazon’s obligations under the EU Digital Services Act (DSA).
We first wrote about the underlying question back in 2012 (Amazon also deletes untrue negative reviews, in German). What has changed since then is mainly the framework within which Amazon has to decide on such notices.
The case: many critical reviews, not all of them challengeable
Our client had a larger number of critical reviews of its product assessed through the LHR Review Check. The traffic-light result was fairly clear: most contained passages that could be challenged. Reviews expressing a lawful opinion with no verifiable core (“feels cheap”, “I don’t like it”) were not reported, and rightly so. From the remaining reviews, the client chose a selection to report.
A typical pattern emerged. A reviewer opens with a value judgement nobody can take away from him and then adds a technical claim that is demonstrably false. Examples from the reviews, paraphrased:
- a function was inferior and did not work reliably,
- a stated value was never reached,
- a component was poorly made,
- the manufacturer’s information about the product was false and the manufacturer was dishonest.
For each of these statements the client explained what was actually behind it: a handling error described in the user manual, a physically explainable effect during use, a skipped maintenance step. Another claim about the product could be refuted with documents. One further review dealt almost entirely with customer service rather than with the product itself.
When does Amazon have to delete a review?
Amazon has to remove a review if it contains untrue statements of fact about the product or the manufacturer, if it amounts to abusive criticism, or if it breaches the platform’s own guidelines. Critical opinions about a product, by contrast, are lawful even when they are sharply worded or seem unfair to the manufacturer. Whether a statement is opinion or fact depends not on its wording but on whether it can be verified by evidence.
“The stated value is never reached” can be checked. “I am disappointed” cannot. Most of the reported reviews mixed the two, and that was the point of attack. Anyone who asserts an untrue fact cannot rely on freedom of expression under Article 5(1) of the German Basic Law (Grundgesetz), even if the claim is wrapped in personal disappointment. For defamatory claims, such as the allegation that the manufacturer was dishonest, the principle behind Section 186 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) puts the burden of proof on the person making the statement, not on the person concerned.
Reviews that deal with shipping, the seller or customer service rather than the product also breach Amazon’s Community Guidelines for customer reviews, regardless of whether they are true.
Legal framework: liability, duty to examine and the DSA
1. Corporate personality rights and injunctive relief
Untrue statements of fact about a product interfere with the manufacturer’s corporate personality right. The claim for removal and injunctive relief follows from Section 1004(1) of the German Civil Code (BGB) by analogy in conjunction with Section 823(1) BGB. For business-damaging falsehoods, Section 824 BGB may also apply.
2. Amazon is liable once it has knowledge
Amazon is not responsible for reviews from the outset, but it is from the moment it learns of a clear infringement. The Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) developed this host-provider liability as early as 2011 (judgment of 25 October 2011, case no. VI ZR 93/10) and later applied it specifically to review platforms (judgment of 1 March 2016, case no. VI ZR 34/15 – Jameda). For hotel reviews it clarified in 2022 that the complaint of the person reviewed is initially sufficient and the portal must then investigate (judgment of 9 August 2022, case no. VI ZR 1244/20). The seller itself, on the other hand, is generally not liable for third-party customer reviews, as we reported on the 2020 BGH ruling (in German).
3. What the Digital Services Act requires of Amazon
Since the DSA, each of our notices is also a notice under Article 16 DSA, on which Amazon must decide in a timely, diligent, objective and non-arbitrary manner. Under Article 14(4) DSA the platform must also enforce its own content rules diligently and proportionately. A notice that quotes the statement complained of, disputes it with reasons and sets the correct facts alongside it is hard to dismiss with a template reply.
Strategy: one review, one letter
We did not send a collective complaint about “unfair reviews” but a separate letter for each review, each with a link to the review, its full wording, the challenged sentences in quotation marks and the client’s response to every single sentence. In addition there was a short version for Amazon’s reporting form, which is limited to a few hundred characters. Amazon decided well before the deadline we had set.
For the review dealing with customer service we relied on the review guidelines rather than on an alleged falsehood, as the breach of the platform’s rules was the shorter route there. In the letters concerning defamatory claims we asked Amazon to forward them to the reviewer, together with a factual reminder of the civil and criminal consequences.
A word on honesty, because it is easily overlooked in practice: the manufacturer’s account must be true. Anyone who denies a defect that actually occurred in order to get rid of an annoying review exposes himself to claims, in the worst case under the very provisions he relies on. That is why the Review Check asks, for every statement of fact, what exactly is untrue, not what is bothersome.
Why Amazon decided so quickly in this case we do not know. The platform gave no reasons for the individual reviews, and Amazon does not give cease-and-desist undertakings in such cases anyway. Whether reviewers will post their texts again, this time without the false claims, remains to be seen. That would, of course, be their right.
What manufacturers and sellers in the same situation can do
- Read each critical review sentence by sentence: what is opinion, what is a verifiable fact, what does not concern the product at all?
- For every challenged statement of fact, write down the actual facts in a verifiable way, for instance with reference to the user manual, a test report or customer correspondence.
- Leave pure opinions alone. Reporting everything dilutes the notices that are well founded.
- Submit a separate, reasoned notice for each review with a reasonable deadline, and check the result on all Amazon marketplaces after a few days.
- If a review stays online despite a reasoned notice, a formal warning letter to Amazon and, if necessary, a preliminary injunction may be considered. From the moment of knowledge, time matters.
That all reported reviews are removed is a fine result, but not a rule. Above all it shows that a platform confronted with a response to every single sentence has less room for standard responses than one that merely reads that the customer is unhappy.
Frequently asked questions
Can a manufacturer have a negative Amazon review removed?
Yes, if the review contains untrue statements of fact, amounts to abusive criticism or breaches Amazon’s review guidelines. A merely critical or unfair opinion about the product, however, has to be tolerated.
How can I tell whether a review contains a statement of fact?
A statement of fact can be checked by evidence, for example the claim that a component is poorly made or a stated value is not reached. Value judgements such as “disappointing” or “too expensive” cannot be proven and are generally lawful.
When is Amazon liable for unlawful reviews?
As a host provider, Amazon is only liable once it learns of a clear infringement and fails to act. A specific, reasoned notice provides that knowledge and, under the Digital Services Act, triggers a duty to decide diligently.
How long does Amazon take to remove a reported review?
It varies considerably and depends on the quality of the notice. In the case described here the confirmation came shortly after the notice, which is a good result and no promise for other cases.
What if Amazon does not delete a review despite a notice?
A formal warning letter to Amazon and, where appropriate, an application for a preliminary injunction may then be considered. Speed matters for urgent proceedings, as many German courts consider urgency lost about one month after knowledge.
False claims about your product in Amazon reviews?
In the LHR Review Check we examine every review sentence by sentence and report challengeable reviews with a lawyer’s letter at a fixed price.
Further information
- Removal of reviews on online marketplaces such as Amazon and eBay
- Removal of negative reviews
- LHR case study: Amazon review used as leverage (in German)
- Fields of activity
- Our successes
Bild: LHR

