Skip to content
LHR Rechtsanwälte, to the home page+49 221 2716733-0Deutsch

LHR case report: removing a Google search result from abroad – why the Munich courts lacked jurisdiction

By Arno Lampmann · Published

An English-language Google snippet, an applicant living outside the EU and two Google companies in Ireland and the United States: for the courts in Munich, this was not a case they were allowed to decide.

We acted for the applicant and lost. That is precisely why it is worth looking at where people living abroad can still have a Google search result removed.

By order of 27 July 2026 (case no. 18 W 1007/26 Pre e), the Higher Regional Court of Munich (Oberlandesgericht München, OLG München) dismissed our client’s immediate appeal against an order of the Regional Court of Munich I (Landgericht München I, LG München I) of 1 July 2026 (case no. 25 O 4254/26). Our client had sought a preliminary injunction prohibiting Google from displaying, in Germany, a search result and snippet which in our view made false allegations of corruption against him. Neither court examined whether the allegations were true, because both held that the German courts lacked international jurisdiction. The Senate did not grant leave to appeal to the Federal Court of Justice.

Law firms are, as a rule, less keen to write about cases they have lost than about those they have won. The order has, however, now been published and is being discussed in the legal press, and it affects anyone who wants to take action against a Google search result from abroad. There is a certain irony in the fact that it was the very same 18th Civil Senate that granted us a preliminary injunction against Google over an unlawful search result (in German) in 2015, and the very same 25th Civil Chamber of the Regional Court that, on our application, prohibited Google from showing a search result about an alleged “suspicion of fraud” (in German) in 2017.

Removing a Google search result from abroad: the case

Our client lives and works outside the European Union. A search for his name returned an English-language snippet linking to an English-language article that accused him of bribery payments. Those payments were alleged neither to have been made in Germany nor to have gone to recipients in Germany. After Google had not removed the search result following our request, we applied to the LG München I for a preliminary injunction against Google Ireland, which operates the search service in Europe, and, as a precaution, against the US company Google LLC.

We had deliberately limited the application to Germany. The aim was not to have the result deleted worldwide, but only to stop it being shown to users in Germany. This seemed the obvious approach, given that the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) had already made clear in 2019 that Google must delist search results across Europe but not worldwide (in German).

Why did the German courts lack jurisdiction over the delisting claim?

In the view of the OLG München, an application for removal or an injunction is “uniform and indivisible” and can therefore only be brought before a court that may decide on the claim as a whole. Under the European rules on jurisdiction, that essentially means the court where the defendant is domiciled and the court at the centre of the claimant’s interests. Neither was in Germany.

The Senate examined the matter under Art. 7(2) of the Brussels Ia Regulation, the jurisdiction rule for torts. In cases of online infringements of personality rights, a claimant may sue not only where the defendant is domiciled under Art. 4 Brussels Ia, but also where the event giving rise to the damage occurred or where the claimant has the centre of his interests. For Google Ireland, the place of the event was Ireland, and our client’s centre of interests was at his habitual residence outside the EU. That left the place where the damage occurred, which under the so-called mosaic approach exists in every state in which the content can be accessed, albeit only for the damage sustained there.

For removal and injunctions, the Senate rejected this route. It relied on the CJEU judgment of 18 June 2026 (Case C-232/25), according to which claims for rectification and removal cannot be split into national portions because online content is accessible worldwide. The fact that our application was framed as an injunction made no difference in the Senate’s view, since it could just as well have been phrased as a request for “removal”. Nor did limiting the application to Germany, in effect a form of geoblocking, make the claim divisible.

Behind this lies a line of reasoning that one can follow even while regretting the outcome. The special jurisdiction under Art. 7(2) Brussels Ia is to be interpreted narrowly and is meant to protect defendants from being sued before courts they could not have anticipated. Neither our client nor Google Ireland is based in Germany, and in the Senate’s view the content had no relevant connection to Germany.

The GDPR does not lead to Germany either

According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH), the right to have search results delisted is based on Art. 17(1) GDPR, and Art. 79(2) GDPR provides its own jurisdiction rule for actions against controllers. That jurisdiction, however, lies either where the controller has an establishment or in the Member State in which the data subject has his or her habitual residence. For Google Ireland, the first option leads to Ireland; for a data subject living outside the EU, the second leads nowhere.

How much connection to Germany does a snippet need?

The Brussels Ia Regulation does not apply to the US company Google LLC, so international jurisdiction is governed by Section 32 of the German Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO). Under this provision, German courts only have jurisdiction over online infringements of personality rights if the content complained of has a clear connection to Germany, meaning that it is considerably more likely to be read in Germany than its mere accessibility would suggest. This reflects the BGH’s approach since its judgment of 2 March 2010 (case no. VI ZR 23/09), which is stricter for personality rights than for copyright, where according to the BGH mere accessibility is sufficient (in German).

The applicant must set out and prove the connection to Germany, which in interim proceedings means establishing it to the court’s satisfaction; a merely conclusive submission was not enough for the Senate. What mattered to the court was the content of the snippet: written in English, without any German facts and not recognisably aimed at an audience in Germany. Neither the fact that many people in Germany understand English nor the fact that the author of the linked article lives in Germany was sufficient. After all, the respondent was Google and not the author.

What the order means for people living abroad

For individuals living outside the EU, the route to a German court against Google has become very narrow. As long as the search result has no genuine connection to Germany, delisting proceedings against Google Ireland will mainly have to be brought at its general place of jurisdiction in Ireland. Anyone living in an EU Member State, by contrast, can bring proceedings at the centre of their interests, which will usually mean in their own country and for the entire claim.

This is particularly unfortunate for interim relief. German press chambers decide quickly, and the Munich courts in particular have for years contributed to Google taking unlawful search results more seriously than it once did. Cases without a connection to Germany will now move to proceedings outside Germany, whose duration and costs are harder for those affected to predict.

Anyone who wants to take action against a Google search result from abroad should therefore clarify a few points before filing the first application:

  • Where is the centre of interests? If the person concerned lives or works in an EU Member State, the courts there will usually be the safest forum.
  • What connection to Germany can be shown? German-language content, events in Germany or a recognisably German audience must be set out in concrete terms and, in interim proceedings, substantiated with evidence.
  • Has the delisting request to Google been made in full? Without sufficiently specific notice of an obvious infringement, the search engine is not liable in any event, and some cases are resolved at this stage.
  • Is there enough time? Anyone who learns only after several weeks that the chosen court lacks jurisdiction may have lost too much time for a fresh application for interim relief.
  • Is there a better respondent? Proceedings against the author or the operator of the source may open up other places of jurisdiction than proceedings against the search engine.

One may regret the decision, and we do. It is, however, consistent and follows the line laid down by the CJEU for removal claims. Whether the BGH will take the same view of injunction claims against search engines in main proceedings remains to be seen; in our client’s case, the order of the OLG München stands.

Frequently asked questions

Can I have a Google search result removed in Germany if I live abroad?

Before a German court, only if that court has international jurisdiction. According to the Higher Regional Court of Munich, that is generally not the case against Google Ireland if neither your residence nor your centre of interests is in Germany, and against Google LLC only if the search result has a clear connection to Germany. Anyone can, however, submit a delisting request directly to Google.

Does it help to limit the application to the display of the result in Germany?

Not in the view of the Munich court. Because online content is accessible worldwide, a claim for removal or an injunction remains uniform and indivisible even if only geoblocking for Germany is sought. It therefore belongs before a court that may decide on the entire claim.

Where can I bring delisting proceedings against Google Ireland?

Always in Ireland, where Google Ireland is based. Anyone whose centre of interests is in an EU Member State can also bring proceedings there, under both Art. 7(2) Brussels Ia and Art. 79(2) GDPR. For people living outside the EU, these options are not available.

What applies to proceedings against the US company Google LLC?

International jurisdiction is then governed by Section 32 of the German Code of Civil Procedure. German courts only have jurisdiction if the content is considerably more likely to be read in Germany than its mere accessibility suggests, and the applicant must set this out and substantiate it. An English-language snippet without any German facts was not enough for the Munich court.

Do I have to ask Google to remove the search result before going to court?

Yes. According to the Federal Court of Justice, a search engine is only liable once it has received sufficiently specific notice of an obvious infringement. A well-reasoned request to Google is therefore a prerequisite for any court action and in some cases achieves the goal on its own.

Is a Google search result damaging your reputation while you live outside Germany?

We assess which court has jurisdiction and whether a request to Google, German proceedings or proceedings abroad is the quicker route. You will usually receive an initial assessment within 24 hours.

Contact us now

Further information

Bild: LHR

Tags

LHR-Magazin

Related articles

  1. 04.04.2017Magazin
Arno Lampmann

Your contact

Arno Lampmann

Partner, Fachanwalt für gewerblichen Rechtsschutz