Skip to content
LHR Rechtsanwälte, to the home page+49 221 2716733-0Deutsch

Black Friday discount without the 30-day price: Regional Court of Bochum finds advertising misleading

By Arno Lampmann · Published

The discount was big, the reference price was missing: an online seller advertised 50 per cent off for Black Friday without saying what the percentage was measured against.

In brief

Outcome
The Regional Court of Bochum (I-15 O 11/26, decision of 1 July 2026) finds an online seller’s Black Friday advertising of 50 per cent off misleading.
Reason
The lowest price of the previous 30 days was missing. The item had cost EUR 32.99 three days earlier and EUR 35 on the sale day.
Consequence
Sellers should state the 30-day price per item (Section 11 PAngV). The decision is not final. An appeal has been lodged.

The Regional Court of Bochum found the advertising misleading. According to the report, the item had cost less three days before the sale than on the day itself.

What did the Regional Court of Bochum decide about Black Friday?

On 1 July 2026 the Regional Court of Bochum (Landgericht Bochum, ref. I-15 O 11/26) objected to the discount advertising of an online seller of motorcycle accessories. The German Centre for Protection against Unfair Competition (Wettbewerbszentrale) reported the decision on 19 November 2026 (in German). It is not final. The seller has appealed.

According to that report, the seller advertised 50 per cent off for Black Friday 2025. A motorcycle bag cost EUR 35 on the sale day and EUR 32.99 three days earlier. Before that, the seller had advertised 27 per cent plus an additional 40 per cent, and on Black Friday 30 per cent plus 50 per cent. It did not state the lowest price of the previous 30 days.

The court found the advertising misleading and in breach of the German Price Indication Ordinance (Preisangabenverordnung, PAngV). The size of the discount should have been based on the lowest price of the 30 days before the reduction. Because of the price increase in between, advertising a high discount with a struck-through price created a false impression.

What does Section 11 PAngV require for a price reduction?

Anyone who must state a total price to consumers must, whenever announcing a price reduction for goods, state the lowest total price applied in the 30 days before the reduction (Section 11(1) PAngV, in German). Where the price is reduced in steps without interruption, the lowest price from before the first step may be stated during the promotion (paragraph 2). Individual price reductions are exempt, as are perishable goods or goods with a short shelf life, provided the reduction is due to imminent spoilage or an imminent expiry of the shelf life and this is made clear to consumers (paragraph 4).

In case C-330/23 (Aldi Süd) the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on 26 September 2024 that a price reduction announced in advertising must be calculated on the basis of the lowest price of the previous 30 days. On 9 October 2025 (I ZR 183/24) Germany’s Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) held Netto’s price-discount advertising unlawful (in German). There, the reference price appeared only in a footnote. The decision follows this line.

What did the tiered and stacked discounts mean in this case?

A percentage in an advert is only as good as the price it refers to. In this case the price rose shortly before the promotion: three days earlier the item cost EUR 32.99, on the sale day EUR 35. The benchmark was therefore at most EUR 32.99, not the last price charged. The special rule for steps in Section 11(2) PAngV only applies where the reduction increases without interruption. The lowest price from before the first step may then be stated. In our reading of Section 11 PAngV, staggered reductions (“27 per cent plus 40 per cent”) do not change the benchmark where the price was raised beforehand.

We reported on the appellate case law on struck-through prices in early October (in German). The Bochum case shows that promotional advertising is not only about the manufacturer’s recommended price but about the seller’s own price history.

What sellers should check before 27 November 2026

Black Friday falls on 27 November this year. Anyone advertising discounts should clarify the following beforehand:

  • For each item, pull the lowest total price of the 30 days before the start of the promotion from your own price data and state it next to the discount.
  • Raising prices shortly before the promotion does not help: the lowest price in the period remains the benchmark.
  • Place the percentage and the reference price so that consumers see them together, including in marketplace listings and ads.
  • Document each item’s price history for the last 30 days (export from the shop system, screenshots) so that you can prove it in a dispute.

Sellers who manage prices on marketplaces will find a parallel in our practice case on a time-limited offer on Amazon (in German). The Bochum decision is not yet final. The appeal court would be the Higher Regional Court of Hamm. Until then, the line taken by the CJEU and the BGH applies in practice.

Frequently asked questions

Does the 30-day rule apply only on Black Friday?

No. Section 11 PAngV applies whenever a price reduction for goods is announced to consumers, including clearance sales, voucher promotions open to all customers and marketplace banners.

Must the percentage be calculated on the 30-day price?

Yes, following the CJEU’s Aldi Süd decision (C-330/23): the announced reduction must be calculated on the lowest price of the previous 30 days.

Which exceptions exist?

Individual price reductions, and perishable goods or goods with a short shelf life reduced because of imminent spoilage or an imminent expiry of the shelf life, if this is made clear (Section 11(4) PAngV).

What happens in case of a breach?

Warning letters from competitors and associations, then injunction proceedings. Have the cease-and-desist declaration reviewed before signing.

Is your Black Friday promotion set up lawfully?

We review discount advertising, price history and marketplace listings before launch, or fend off a warning letter. You will usually receive a first assessment within 24 hours.

Contact us now (in German)

Further information

LHR-Magazin

More articles

  1. 21.11.2026Magazin
  2. 13.11.2026Magazin
  3. 12.11.2026Magazin
Arno Lampmann

Your contact

Arno Lampmann

Partner, Fachanwalt für gewerblichen Rechtsschutz