Skip to content
LHR Rechtsanwälte, to the home page+49 221 2716733-0Deutsch

Discounts only with an app: BGH hears on 25 February 2027 whether this disadvantages older people

By Arno Lampmann · Published

A yoghurt for 33 cents instead of 44, but only with the app. Anyone who does not use or cannot use a smartphone pays more.

In brief

Status
The BGH hears the case on 25 February 2027 (I ZR 214/26). There is no decision yet.
Dispute
The claimant says older people and people with disabilities are disadvantaged. The Hamm court (I-13 UKl 7/25, 16 April 2026) dismissed the action and allowed an appeal.
Consequence
Retailers should document their reasons and consider a route without a smartphone. We do not expect a blanket ban.

On 25 February 2027 the German Federal Court of Justice will hear the case on whether this unlawfully disadvantages older people and people with disabilities.

The Higher Regional Court of Hamm dismissed the consumer organisations’ action but allowed an appeal on points of law.

What the Federal Court of Justice will hear on 25 February 2027

The First Civil Senate of the German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) has scheduled a hearing in case I ZR 214/26 for 25 February 2027 at 10:00. The court announced this in its press release no. 219/2026 of 11 November 2026 (in German). The question is whether a food retailer “unlawfully disadvantages older people and people with disabilities” by granting discounts exclusively through a shopping app (our translation).

The defendant operates food stores and provides a smartphone app that stores purchase data. Changing discounts go only to app users, in the case at hand a yoghurt for 33 instead of 44 cents. According to the press release of the Higher Regional Court of Hamm (in German) on the lower court’s judgment, the defendant is Penny Markt GmbH. The claimant is the umbrella organisation of the German consumer advice centres, which seeks an injunction and reimbursement of its warning costs.

What the Higher Regional Court of Hamm decided

On 16 April 2026 (I-13 UKl 7/25) the Higher Regional Court of Hamm (Oberlandesgericht Hamm) dismissed the action (in German) and allowed an appeal on points of law. According to the BGH’s press release, it found no direct discrimination because the app is open to everyone through its registration process. The claimant had not sufficiently substantiated indirect discrimination. In the alternative, the design was justified, since providing and designing the app was “a legal entrepreneurial decision of the defendant” (our translation).

The judgment is not final. We found no earlier BGH decisions on this question. The Hamm judgment is the lower-court decision.

Why Section 19 AGG may decide the case

The court will examine sections 1, 3 and 19 of the German General Act on Equal Treatment (Allgemeines Gleichbehandlungsgesetz, AGG). Under Section 19(1) no. 1 AGG (in German), discrimination on a protected ground, including age and disability, is prohibited in transactions that typically arise “without regard to the person under comparable conditions” (our translation). A supermarket purchase is the textbook example. The main dispute is whether there is a disadvantage.

Direct discrimination means being treated worse because of the protected characteristic. That is hard to argue for an app anyone can download. Indirect discrimination remains: a neutral rule that typically hits older people or people with disabilities harder. The Hamm court required the claimant to substantiate that. This is probably what the case will turn on: figures on usage and on alternatives. We do not expect a blanket ban on app discounts. A ruling that clarifies the requirements for substantiation and objective justification is more likely.

What retailers with loyalty apps should check now

There is no decision yet, and the BGH may also dismiss the appeal. Retailers who offer discounts exclusively digitally should nevertheless not postpone the question until February:

  • Document why tying the offer to the app is commercially necessary, for example for managing promotions or bonus systems.
  • Check whether there is an equivalent route without a smartphone, such as a card or coupons at the till.
  • Make registration and use of the app low-barrier and point out in-store help with registration.
  • Keep discount communication clean. We reported on strike-through prices and the lowest-price rule before Black Friday (in German).
  • Review data protection separately. The press release does not mention the GDPR. The storage of purchase data remains a separate issue.

Those on the other side, such as associations or affected consumers, should collect figures. Whether the appeal succeeds or fails on substantiation is the most interesting question of the case.

Frequently asked questions

Must retailers abolish app discounts now?

No. There is no BGH decision, and the Hamm court dismissed the action. The date of 25 February 2027 is the oral hearing. No date for a decision has been announced yet.

Does Section 19 AGG apply only to food retail?

No. The provision covers mass transactions in all sectors. Anyone who links benefits to an app or an account in drugstores, at petrol stations or in online retail should keep an eye on the decision.

What can an affected customer do until the decision?

They can ask the retailer in writing to grant the discount without the app and keep the reply. Whether any claims follow depends on the outcome of the proceedings.

Does data protection play a role in these proceedings?

According to the press release, no. The app stores purchase data, but the subject of the dispute is the AGG and the Injunctions Act (UKlaG). Consent and transparency under the GDPR must be assessed independently.

Does your business offer discounts via an app, an account or a loyalty card?

We review whether your model withstands discrimination, competition and data protection law. You will usually receive a first assessment within 24 hours.

Contact us now (in German)

Further information

LHR-Magazin

More articles

  1. 13.11.2026Magazin
  2. 21.11.2026Magazin
  3. 12.11.2026Magazin
Arno Lampmann

Your contact

Arno Lampmann

Partner, Fachanwalt für gewerblichen Rechtsschutz