By Arno Lampmann · Published
MagazinneuA competitor arranges test purchases, sends a warning letter, the warning letter is rejected and an application for a preliminary injunction follows. Nothing unusual so far. This time, however, the application came too late, even though only five weeks lay between the warning letter and the application.
In brief
- Outcome
- By order of 18 November 2026 (10 O 1590/26), the Regional Court of Kassel dismissed a competitor’s application for a preliminary injunction against an online retailer without examining the merits. The order is not yet final.
- Reason
- 47 days passed between the first test purchase and the application. A second test purchase of the same facts does not restart the urgency period, and the applicant waited almost three more weeks after the warning letter had been rejected.
- Consequence
- Anyone seeking a preliminary injunction must act swiftly once aware of the infringement. In Hesse six weeks serve as a rough guideline, and additional test purchases do not extend the period.
Why the clock started running with the first test purchase, and why a second test purchase does not reset it, is shown by a decision of the Regional Court of Kassel in a current case handled by our firm.
By order of 18 November 2026 (file no. 10 O 1590/26), the Regional Court of Kassel (Landgericht Kassel) dismissed a competitor’s application for a preliminary injunction against our client, an online retailer. The 10th civil chamber did not even examine whether the statements complained of were unfair. There was no ground for urgency, the court held, because the applicant had waited too long. The applicant has to bear the costs of the proceedings; the order is not yet final.
Urgency for a preliminary injunction: how long may you wait?
In German unfair competition law, an applicant does not have to show urgency separately, because Section 12(1) of the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG) presumes it. The presumption can be rebutted, however, and the applicant usually rebuts it himself by remaining inactive for too long after learning of the infringement. There is no fixed deadline. In the district of the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main (Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt), which includes Kassel, six weeks serve as a rough guideline.
The Regional Court of Kassel relied on the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt (judgment of 11 November 2021, file no. 6 U 121/21). What matters, it said, is whether the applicant’s delay shows that the matter is “not that urgent” for him (Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt, judgment of 6 December 2018, file no. 6 U 125/18). Other courts are stricter; the Higher Regional Court of Hamm, for example, set the limit at one month years ago (in German). All courts agree on when the period starts: with knowledge of all relevant circumstances, not with the warning letter, and certainly not with the reply of the party warned.
The case: two test purchases, one warning letter and seven weeks
The applicant, a competitor of our client, had two test purchases made from our client. The first was completed on 3 September 2026. On that basis, the applicant sent a warning letter alleging, among other things, misleading statements on delivery times and on when the withdrawal period begins for partial deliveries. On behalf of our client, we rejected the warning letter by letter of 27 September 2026.
Then nothing happened for a while. The application only reached the Regional Court of Kassel on 20 October 2026, 47 days after the first test purchase and around three weeks after our rejection. In between lay a second test purchase documenting the same facts once more. The applicant evidently relied on it, because counting from the second purchase makes the timeline look considerably friendlier.
Does a second test purchase restart the urgency period?
No. A further test purchase that merely documents essentially the same facts again neither suspends the urgency period nor starts it anew. The Regional Court of Kassel said so expressly. In the chamber’s view, once the first test purchase had been completed and evaluated, the applicant had all the facts it needed to assess the legal position reliably and to go to court.
The second test purchase was therefore necessary neither to establish the facts nor to substantiate them. That is convincing. Anyone who buys the same infringement a second time knows no more than before; at most, he has a further piece of evidence for something he could already prove. If the period could be extended in this way, any applicant could buy himself as much time as he liked with a new test purchase, and the presumption in Section 12(1) UWG would become a blank cheque.
Nor did the chamber see any reasons that could have justified a longer preparation. The facts were not exceptionally complex, and there were no particular legal difficulties. That is the normal case for warning letters about statements in an online shop, and for the normal case six weeks are ample.
Three weeks of waiting after the rejection: the applicant rebuts itself
For the chamber, the applicant’s own procedural conduct settled the question of urgency for good. After our client had expressly rejected the claims, the applicant let almost three more weeks pass before going to court. Anyone who waits that long after his claims have been finally rejected shows, in the court’s view, that enforcing them is not urgent for him.
This is where applicants misjudge the situation surprisingly often. The rejection of a warning letter is not a new starting signal but a sign that nothing more can be achieved out of court. Anyone who is really in a hurry files the application at the latest now, ideally having prepared it long ago. Anyone who waits instead is not collecting arguments, only days.
A case before the same chamber, which we reported on only recently, shows the other side. There the application followed barely two weeks after the warning letter, and the Regional Court of Kassel heard the case on the merits; we were able to fend off five of seven allegations (in German). Conversely, only positive knowledge of the infringement starts the period. There is no general duty to monitor the market, as we described in another case study on urgency (in German), in which the other side tried to bring the period forward using tracking data.
What recipients and senders of warning letters should take away
The order ends the summary proceedings at first instance, not necessarily the dispute. The applicant can lodge an immediate appeal under Section 567 of the German Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO) within two weeks of service, and it can still bring an action on the merits. There urgency plays no role, but there is no quick injunction either. In practice, the case suggests the following:
- The urgency period begins with knowledge of the infringement; for test purchases, usually with the completion and evaluation of the first purchase, not with the warning letter.
- Further test purchases of the same infringement do not extend the period. Anyone who wants to add evidence must do so within the running period.
- Which period applies depends on the court: in Hesse six weeks serve as a guideline, other higher regional courts draw the line after one month.
- After a warning letter has been rejected, the application should follow within days. Courts treat weeks of waiting as a lack of urgency.
- Recipients of warning letters should record the dates of the test purchase, delivery, warning letter and their own reply and set them out in a protective letter for the central register (Section 945a ZPO), so that the court knows them before deciding without a hearing.
Whether the competitor’s allegations had any merit was a question the court no longer had to answer; we consider them unfounded. Summary proceedings exist for those who are in a hurry. Anyone who takes his time will get it, but in proceedings on the merits.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to apply for a preliminary injunction in German unfair competition law?
There is no statutory deadline. Courts ask whether the applicant’s delay shows that the matter is not urgent for him. In the district of the Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt, around six weeks from knowledge serve as a rough guideline; many other courts draw the line after about one month.
When does the urgency period start after a test purchase?
As a rule, once the test purchase has been completed and evaluated. At that point the competitor knows all the facts needed for the application. The date of the warning letter or of the reply to it is irrelevant.
Does a second test purchase extend the urgency period?
No, at least not if it merely documents the same infringement again. The Regional Court of Kassel held that such a test purchase neither suspends nor restarts the period. Further evidence must be obtained within the running period.
Is the claim lost if urgency is missing?
No. Only the route via summary proceedings is closed. The claim can still be pursued in an action on the merits, which takes considerably longer.
Received a warning letter or an application for a preliminary injunction in Germany?
We review the allegations and the timeline since the test purchase and the warning letter and tell you whether a defence is worthwhile and whether a protective letter makes sense. You will usually receive an initial assessment within 24 hours.

