By Arno Lampmann · Published
MagazinneuA German appellate court refuses to hold a hearing by video because maintaining a stable audio and video connection would cost the judges too much time. The lawyer who publicly calls that "lazy" is reported to his bar association.
One may argue about the lawyer's tone. The pattern the case exposes deserves less argument and more attention.
Video hearing refused – because of the effort for the judges
In appeal proceedings between two law firms (case no. I-4 U 176/25), the 4th Civil Senate of the Higher Regional Court of Hamm (Oberlandesgericht Hamm, OLG Hamm) refused, by letter of 16 April 2026, an application to attend the hearing by video under Section 128a of the German Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO). The reasoning consists of a single sentence: permission was out of the question in view of the expected and unacceptable additional time the judges would need to set up and maintain a stable audio and video transmission.
The defendant was the law firm of a fellow lawyer who published the letter on X and commented that the judges at the OLG Hamm were regularly too lazy to allow online hearings. On 22 May 2026 a judge at the OLG Hamm, head of one of the court's departments, forwarded the post by email to the Cologne Bar Association (Rechtsanwaltskammer Köln), asking for a review under the rules of professional conduct. He published that email as well. The bar association has since replied.
The lawyer in question is neither a sympathetic figure nor someone to feel sorry for. He is hardly a model of measured criticism of the judiciary, and anyone who calls judges "lazy" in public should expect a reaction. The case is instructive nonetheless, because it exposes something we have been observing in our own practice for some time.
What Section 128a ZPO requires of the courts
Since the 2024 reform, a German civil court is to grant a party's application to participate by video if the case is suitable and sufficient capacity is available (Section 128a(1) and (3) ZPO). A refusal must state brief reasons and cannot be appealed (Section 128a(7) ZPO). Once applied for, the video hearing is therefore no longer a favour but the default the legislature intended.
The judges' "unacceptable additional time" is not a criterion in the statute. Capacity means rooms and equipment, not the willingness of a senate to use them. This is all the more striking at the OLG Hamm, whose own website explains in detail how to join the court's video hearings through the virtual meeting rooms of the North Rhine-Westphalian judiciary. The technology exists. It is simply not used.
Standard paragraphs instead of discretion?
The Hamm reasoning is unusually candid, but not an isolated case. More and more of our applications under Section 128a ZPO are refused with wording that reads suspiciously like a template: the video format would not do justice to the case, the hearing would be technically impossible or too burdensome, or the court needed to see the parties' facial expressions even where no evidence is to be taken. A genuine engagement with the specific proceedings is rare.
That this is not merely a lawyer's grievance is shown by a decision of the Constitutional Court of Baden-Württemberg (VerfGH BW) of 8 December 2025 (case no. 1 VB 64/25). The Local Court of Freiburg had refused a severely disabled party who was unable to travel permission to attend by video, in one sentence, citing a lack of suitable equipment. The constitutional court dismissed the complaint as inadmissible because a motion for recusal should have been filed first. It made clear, however, that the judge should have made an effort to obtain the equipment and, if necessary, raised the issue with the court's administration, and it openly voiced the impression that technical problems had merely been put forward to avoid the burdens of Section 128a ZPO.
It is hard to avoid the impression that some courts shy away from the effort that the video hearing, now the statutory default, entails. The technology is proven and used reliably by millions every day. Lawyers, incidentally, are held to strict standards when explaining technical failures, for example when filing through the German electronic lawyers' mailbox (beA), whereas a single sentence suffices on the bench. We have previously described how courts use procedural hurdles to avoid unwelcome work (in German). The refused video hearing fits that picture.
Who pays for the trip to Munich?
It becomes particularly frustrating when one has to travel across the country for a hearing, only to be pushed towards a settlement there. The warning is predictable: without an agreement, a further hearing with witness evidence will be needed, and everything will become costly and time-consuming. That is true. But it is costly mainly because the first hearing was not allowed to take place by video.
A return trip from Cologne to Munich including the hearing easily takes a full working day, often with an overnight stay and the corresponding loss of time in the office. At an hourly rate of EUR 400, claims below EUR 5,000 become commercially unviable under these conditions, since the statutory fees do not come close to covering that effort. The right of access to justice, which the Federal Constitutional Court derives from the rule of law, is thus restricted not by a judgment but by the travel bill. Parties with small claims either give up their rights or their lawyer, and neither can have been the intention of a legislature that created Section 128a ZPO precisely for such cases.
May a lawyer call judges "lazy"?
The wording of the submission is telling in itself. The judge asked for a review under "Standesrecht", the old German term for a code of professional etiquette for lawyers. That body of rules has not existed since the so-called Bastille decisions of the Federal Constitutional Court of 14 July 1987, which held that the bar associations' guidelines on professional conduct could no longer serve as a basis for restricting lawyers' practice. They were replaced by professional law laid down in the Federal Lawyers' Act and the Rules of Professional Practice, and the bar association's reply accordingly speaks, without comment, of "professional law". One may consider this a trifle. We see it as further evidence of a mindset in which the lawyer is a member of an estate who must behave towards authority, a mindset that has evidently survived the past decades better among some judges than the old rules themselves.
The Cologne Bar Association has answered that question for this case. Its board dealt with the submission from Hamm on 30 September 2026 and took no measures. No professional misconduct could be established, it said, as the statements were "(still)" covered by freedom of expression.
That comes as no surprise. The duty of objectivity under Section 43a(3) of the Federal Lawyers' Act (BRAO) prohibits knowingly spreading falsehoods and disparaging remarks for which neither other parties nor the course of the proceedings gave cause. Here, the senate supplied the cause itself by citing its own workload. We would have chosen different words, and the "still" in brackets may well be read as a hint from the bar association. Still, a court that justifies a procedural decision with the judges' workload and then has criticism of it reviewed under professional rules should not be surprised if this is understood as a response to the criticism rather than as concern for professional ethics.
What lawyers and parties can do when a court refuses a video hearing
There is no appeal, and an inadmissible complaint may even result in costs for the lawyer personally, as the Regional Court of Lübeck has shown (case no. 7 T 179/25). Practical options remain:
- Apply early and give specific reasons: travel distance, time required, amount in dispute, no taking of evidence. The more specific the application, the harder it is to refuse it in one sentence.
- Involve the other side. A joint application by all parties leaves the court little room for doubts about the suitability of the case.
- Offer a test connection and refer to the court's own equipment. If the refusal remains generic, ask in writing which capacity is actually lacking.
- Raise the cost issue openly in settlement discussions when the court warns that further proceedings will be costly.
- Consider a motion for recusal only as a last resort. The Higher Regional Court of Stuttgart saw no ground for bias in refusing a video hearing because of complexity and the amount in dispute (order of 10 March 2025, case no. 3 W 10/25), whereas the VerfGH BW pointed the other way where reasons are obviously pretextual.
The legislature has made the video hearing the default. Whether it becomes one in practice will be decided not in the Federal Law Gazette but in the court registries.
Frequently asked questions about refused video hearings
Does a German court have to allow a video hearing if I apply for one?
Under Section 128a(3) ZPO the court is to grant the application if the case is suitable and sufficient capacity is available. There is no enforceable right, however, and the court only has to give brief reasons for a refusal.
Can I appeal against the refusal of a video hearing?
No. Decisions under Section 128a ZPO cannot be challenged (subsection 7). A complaint filed anyway will be rejected and may cause costs, in one case even for the lawyer personally.
Is the judges’ workload a permissible reason for refusing a video hearing?
The statute looks at the suitability of the case and at available capacity, meaning rooms and equipment. The time judges need to maintain a stable connection is not a criterion of Section 128a ZPO, particularly as the courts in North Rhine-Westphalia have their own video conferencing systems.
Does a motion for recusal help if the court refuses a video hearing?
Only in exceptional cases. The Higher Regional Court of Stuttgart saw no bias in a refusal based on complexity and the amount in dispute. The Constitutional Court of Baden-Württemberg indicated, however, that obviously pretextual technical reasons may justify concerns of bias.
Has a German court refused your video hearing or is it pushing you towards a settlement?
We advise on how to substantiate an application under Section 128a ZPO and how to deal with cost pressure in German proceedings. You will usually receive an initial assessment within 24 hours.
Further information
- Prozessuale Hürden statt Rechtsprechung (in German)
- BGH: Darlegung technischer Probleme bei beA-Einreichung (in German)
- Our successes (in German)
Bild: LHR
