Skip to content
LHR Rechtsanwälte, to the home page+49 221 2716733-0Deutsch

LHR case study: “AI content” on real photos – Frankfurt court prohibits false AI label and missing photo credit

Photo print of a car in a hall, a sticky note covers part of the picture

AI LABEL BANNEDLG Frankfurt · 2-06 O 414/26

By Arno Lampmann · Published

Everyone is debating when AI content has to be labelled. Our case shows the flip side: genuine photographs that suddenly appear online as “AI content”.

In brief

Outcome
By order of 17 November 2026 (2-06 O 414/26), the Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main prohibited by preliminary injunction publishing a photographer’s genuine photos with the label “AI content” and without his name.
Reason
An AI label presents the photos as machine-generated and denies the photographer’s authorship (Section 13 UrhG). The person publishing the post is responsible, even if the platform adds the label.
Consequence
Anyone who edits third-party pictures with AI tools and posts them risks an injunction. Setting a profile to private does not remove the risk of repetition.

For the photographer this is more than an annoyance. The label denies him his work, and the Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main has prohibited it by preliminary injunction.

By order of 17 November 2026 (case no. 2-06 O 414/26), the Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main (Landgericht Frankfurt am Main) granted a preliminary injunction on our application in favour of a photographer. Among other things, the respondent is prohibited from publishing our client’s photographs with the label “AI content”. The chamber decided without an oral hearing and granted every point applied for. The order is not yet final.

The facts are quickly told. A business had commissioned the photographs for its social media channels, orally and without a written contract. Later they appeared on Instagram without the photographer’s name and, in one post, retouched. That very post carried the label “AI content”.

Such a label presents the pictures as wholly or partly machine-generated. Anyone reading it takes the photographs for the output of a program rather than the work of a person. This denies the photographer his authorship, which is exactly what Section 13 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) protects against, for simple photographs in conjunction with Section 72 UrhG. The right to be recognised as author is therefore infringed not only by leaving out the name, but also by attributing the pictures to a machine.

Whether the user added the label himself or the platform applied it automatically, for instance because the pictures had been edited with an AI tool, makes no difference. The user published the post and is responsible for what appears under it. Of all things, it was the retouching that made someone else’s pictures look like machine output.

Why the issue matters right now

Labelling AI content is one of the big topics of the moment. Article 50 of the EU AI Act requires transparency for deepfakes and certain AI-generated texts, and platforms now often add labels themselves as soon as they detect traces of AI in a file. We have described elsewhere how retailers get caught between labelling duties and platform rules (in German). The opposite risk has received little attention so far: a label that presents genuine work as AI is a problem of its own for creatives.

For photographers, illustrators and videographers, their reputation depends on their work remaining recognisable as theirs. An “AI content” label easily suggests that the author works with generators or that the pictures are interchangeable. Incidentally, the Regional Court of Frankfurt am Main recently also dealt with the line between human creation and AI in a case on AI music (in German).

What else the court prohibited

The AI label was not the only infringement. The chamber also prohibited showing the photographs without crediting the author. Under Section 13 UrhG this right also exists against anyone permitted to use the pictures. A waiver must be agreed. The Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) held in 2023 that this is possible even in standard terms, as we reported (in German). There was no such agreement here.

Also prohibited is the use of a photograph on the business’s website. Without an express agreement, a licence only extends as far as the purpose of the contract requires (Section 31(5) UrhG), and a social media commission does not, in case of doubt, cover one’s own website. Finally, the court prohibited the retouched version with replaced lettering in the background (Section 23 UrhG, Section 39 UrhG) and a picture credit attributing the photographs to the business itself.

Switching the profile to private is not enough

The respondent’s only reaction to our pre-trial letter was to switch his Instagram profile to “private”. That does not remove the risk of repetition, which only a cease-and-desist declaration with a contractual penalty can do, and a profile can be reopened with one click. The Higher Regional Court of Cologne (Oberlandesgericht Köln) once denied urgency because an infringement had been fully discontinued before the application, as we reported (in German). Here, however, the use on the website continued.

In German copyright law urgency is not presumed. The author has to substantiate it. What counts is when he learnt of the infringement and the infringer. Waiting too long forfeits urgency. Here, the application was filed promptly after the author learnt of the infringement.

What creatives and clients should take from this

  • Anyone editing third-party pictures with AI tools should check before posting whether the platform adds an AI label. The user is liable for the label, even if he did not choose it.
  • Photographers should record attribution and the purpose of use in writing before the job. An e-mail is enough.
  • Clients may use photographs without a specific agreement only for the agreed purpose. Website, print and advertising are separate uses.
  • Anyone who discovers an infringement should note the date, secure all instances and act quickly. For a preliminary injunction, weeks count.
  • Once granted, the injunction must be served within one month. After that, any breach can lead to a coercive fine (in German).

The injunction initially secures only the cease and desist. Information and damages follow separately. What courts award for photographs we have described here (in German). That false AI labels will keep the courts busy more often in future seems to us fairly certain.

Frequently asked questions

May genuine photos be labelled “AI content”?

Not third-party photos without the author’s consent. The label presents them as machine-generated and denies the photographer’s authorship, which infringes his right to recognition under Section 13 UrhG.

Who is liable if Instagram adds the AI label automatically?

The user who publishes the post. He decides what he shows and must check how the platform presents his post. Anyone editing pictures with AI tools should expect such a label to appear.

Do I have to credit the photographer if I paid for the photos?

Yes, unless agreed otherwise. Under German law the right to attribution also applies against clients. A waiver must be agreed, which according to the Federal Court of Justice is possible even in standard terms.

May I use photos commissioned for Instagram on my website?

Only if agreed. Without an express agreement, the scope of the licence follows the purpose of the contract (Section 31(5) UrhG). A social media commission does not, in case of doubt, cover one’s own website.

Is it enough to set the profile to private after a warning letter?

No. The risk of repetition is only removed by a cease-and-desist declaration with a contractual penalty. A private profile can be reopened at any time.

Are your photos or videos online without your name or with a false AI label?

We review the instances, licences and deadlines and tell you whether a warning letter or a preliminary injunction is an option. You will usually receive an initial assessment within 24 hours.

Contact us now

Further information

Tags

Arno Lampmann

Your contact

Arno Lampmann

Partner, Fachanwalt für gewerblichen Rechtsschutz