By Arno Lampmann · Published
MagazinneuFor years, a well-known German singer told interviewers what her ideal man would have to be like, why an engagement fell through and that “the whole world” would surely find out once there was someone new.
When two websites then reported the name, age and profession of her alleged new partner, she sued. The Berlin Court of Appeal sided with her. The Federal Court of Justice did not.
In a judgment of 6 October 2026 (case no. VI ZR 69/26), the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) dismissed in full an action for an injunction brought by a singer and TV presenter known throughout Germany against the operator of the websites tvmovie.de and wunderweib.de. In January 2023, citing the tabloid Bild, the websites had reported that the singer had been dating a German-Turkish politician for several months and identified him by name, age and political background. The claimant, incidentally, never alleged that the report was untrue.
The Regional Court of Berlin II (Landgericht Berlin II, judgment of 23 April 2024, case no. 27 O 304/23) and the Berlin Court of Appeal (Kammergericht, judgment of 19 March 2026, case no. 10 U 67/24) had drawn what looked like a Solomonic line: the media could report that she was no longer single, but not who the new man was. The Higher Regional Court of Cologne (Oberlandesgericht Köln) had already taken a different view in earlier interim proceedings between the same parties, and the Berlin court expressly departed from it. The BGH’s Sixth Civil Senate has now set aside the Berlin judgment and decided the case itself.
Reporting on a new partner affects privacy
Reporting on the new partner of a celebrity interferes with her privacy, even if she has talked a lot about her love life. That alone does not make it unlawful. Whether the press may name the partner depends on a balancing exercise against press freedom under Article 5(1) of the German Basic Law (Grundgesetz).
The court confirms its established case law that information about a romantic relationship the person concerned wishes to keep secret falls within the protected sphere of the general right of personality (Article 2(1) in conjunction with Article 1(1) Basic Law, Article 8 ECHR). It rejects the argument that the singer had waived that protection altogether by opening up her private life. Since a relationship ended in 2014, she had never spoken about a specific new partnership. Her remark on television in 2020 that the whole world would find out once there was news was, in the court’s view, an announcement, not a disclosure.
May the press name a celebrity’s new partner?
Yes, if the public interest in the information prevails, and according to the BGH it will do so above all where the celebrity herself has created that interest. Anyone who repeatedly and specifically talks about their own love life will find it hard to argue later that the identity of their new partner, of all things, is nobody’s business.
The court went through the claimant’s statements from 2017 to 2020 as established by the Court of Appeal. She had spoken about many dates, about an engagement she regretted the day after saying yes, about the humour, spontaneity and patience she expected from a future partner, about a world trip she wanted to take with the man of her life and about how strict she would be about infidelity. The Court of Appeal had seen this essentially as part of her stage persona and as justifying, at most, an interest in her relationship status. The BGH disagrees: she had not merely disclosed her status but given insights that would otherwise have remained hidden from the public. The public was therefore entitled to learn which specific person matched the wishes she had expressed in public, and that he came not from show business but from politics.
The tone of the reporting is irrelevant. Entertainment journalism about the private lives of celebrities also enjoys the protection of press freedom, because celebrities, according to settled case law, serve as role models or as contrasts. Readers who object to a celebrity being called the “hottest bachelorette” may do so on grounds of taste; legally, it does not help.
An interference, but not a serious one
On the other side of the scales, the court sees an interference that is not trivial but not serious either. Reporting that and with whom someone is in a new relationship gives a deeper insight into their life than merely reporting that they are no longer single. In itself, however, it is not a serious interference, as the BGH had already held in 2022 in the case of a comedian and a blogger (judgment of 2 August 2022, case no. VI ZR 26/21), on which we reported at the time (in German).
A further point against the claimant was that, according to the Court of Appeal’s findings, she had never visibly tried to keep her private life secret in a way the editors had knowingly disregarded. Under the court’s case law, anyone who wants to shield their private life must do so consistently and across situations. The singer had done the opposite.
One question remains open because the judgment did not have to answer it: the rights of the partner. He was not a party to the proceedings, is, according to the findings, unknown to the wider public and, as far as can be seen, never commented on the relationship. The judgment does not say that the singer’s openness binds him as well, and we consider that doubtful. The Berlin Court of Appeal had expressly held the reporting to be unlawful as far as he was concerned.
What celebrities and editors should take from the ruling
The judgment is instructive for both sides, well beyond the world of pop music. It applies to anyone in public life who gives interviews, whether presenter, entrepreneur or influencer.
- Anyone who talks in interviews about what they want in a partner, about break-ups or family plans opens up a topic. Distinguishing between “relationship status yes, identity of the partner no” no longer works as a matter of course.
- Mere announcements are not a disclosure, but they feed into the overall assessment and strengthen the public interest.
- Those who want to protect their privacy in future should do so visibly and consistently, for example through a clear line towards the media and on their own social media channels.
- Editors should carefully document earlier statements by the person concerned. In court, it is precisely these quotes that decide the balancing exercise.
- Partners and other third parties who are not themselves in the public eye should have their own claims examined separately, and quickly if interim relief is an option.
We have reported several times on celebrities who failed in their attempt to close a door they had once opened; an early example is the letter to the editor by TV host Stefan Raab (in German) from 2011. Conversely, the decision on the right of reply obtained by former national football coach Joachim Löw (in German) shows that untrue relationship reports can be fought. Here, however, the report was apparently true.
In 2020, the singer announced that the whole world would find out once there was someone new. According to the BGH, the fact that the world then learned of it from the press rather than from her is her risk.
Frequently asked questions
May the press report who a celebrity is dating in Germany?
That depends on balancing privacy against press freedom. According to the Federal Court of Justice, the public interest prevails at least where the celebrity has repeatedly and specifically discussed her love life in public. Merely reporting a relationship is not regarded as a serious interference.
What does self-disclosure mean under German personality law?
Anyone who makes certain private matters public cannot rely on privacy protection to that extent. A withdrawal into privacy must be recognisable consistently and across situations. Even without full self-disclosure, earlier statements can considerably strengthen the public interest in the balancing exercise.
Is it enough to disclose only one’s relationship status?
The Berlin Court of Appeal distinguished between the status and the identity of the partner. The Federal Court of Justice did not follow this because the singer had disclosed far more than her status, such as her wishes for a partner and a failed engagement. Someone who briefly says they are taken is therefore in a better position than someone who has talked about their love life at length for years.
Can the named partner take action against the reporting himself?
The court did not have to decide this because the partner was not a party. A person who is not in public life and has never commented has his own right of personality, which does not automatically yield to the statements of a famous partner. Whether a claim exists must be examined case by case.
Does it matter whether the relationship report is true?
For reports from the private sphere, what matters primarily is not the truth but whether there is a legitimate public interest. Untrue relationship reports can, in addition, be challenged by injunction, correction or a right of reply. In the case decided, the claimant had not disputed the accuracy of the report.
A German medium is reporting on your private life or relationship and you want to know whether you have to accept it?
We review the reporting and your earlier public statements and tell you whether an injunction, a right of reply or interim proceedings make sense. You will usually receive an initial assessment within 24 hours.
Further information
Bild: LHR
